Chapter 10: Magnetism

In the year 1600, a London physician named William Gilbert published a book on magnets. For centuries sailors had trusted the compass without knowing why it worked. Some believed that a huge mountain of lodestone stood somewhere in the far north and pulled the needle towards itself. Others thought the Pole star was doing the pulling.

Gilbert decided to test the idea rather than argue about it. He had a lump of lodestone cut and ground into a smooth ball, which he called a ‘terrella’ — a little earth. Then he took a tiny compass needle and moved it, point by point, across the surface of that stone ball.

Near the middle of the sphere the needle lay flat. As he carried it towards either end, the needle tilted more and more steeply, until close to the ends it stood almost upright.

Now, sailors had been reporting exactly this behaviour for years. A needle free to swing in a vertical plane lies level near the equator, and dips more and more steeply as a ship sails far to the north. Gilbert’s little stone ball was behaving just like the Earth.

So he drew a bold conclusion. Nothing distant is pulling on the compass at all. The Earth is itself a great magnet, and the needle simply turns to line up with the Earth’s own magnetic field.

Diagram

Fig. 10.0-1 — Gilbert’s Terrella A smooth sphere of lodestone resting on a small wooden stand, with a tiny compass needle drawn at five positions around its surface: lying flat and parallel to the surface at the middle of the sphere, tilted at a small angle a little above and below the middle, tilted steeply nearer the top and bottom, and standing almost vertical at the very top and bottom. Label the sphere ‘terrella (ball of lodestone)’, label the flat position ‘needle lies level here’, label the vertical position ‘needle stands upright here’, and draw a dotted line round the middle of the sphere.

NoteCuriosity Corner

Q1. A magnet hung from a thread swings for a while and then stops — and it always stops pointing the same way. Why should one particular direction be special? Q2. An iron nail is not a magnet, yet it clings to a magnet and can even hold a second nail hanging below it. Where does the nail get its magnetism from, and why does it lose it so quickly? Q3. Two magnetic field lines may run very close together, but they never cross. What would go wrong if two of them did cross at a point? Q4. If the Earth really behaves like a huge magnet, which kind of magnetic pole must lie near the geographic north — and how could you work that out from a compass alone? Q5. Around a bar magnet lying on a table there are two points where a compass needle refuses to settle in any particular direction. What must be happening to the magnetic field there?

10.1 Magnets, Poles And Their Behaviour

10.1.1 Lodestone And Natural Magnets

The first magnets anyone knew about were not made in a workshop. They were lumps of a dark, heavy rock dug out of the ground. This rock is called lodestone — a naturally occurring ore of iron oxide, \(\\mathrm{Fe\_3O\_4}\), which was found in large quantities in Magnesia, a district in Asia Minor.

Lodestone was noticed because it did two odd things that ordinary stones do not do. First, it attracted small pieces of iron lying near it. Second, when a piece of it was hung up so that it could turn freely, it always settled along one particular direction and stayed there.

That second property is the useful one. It was known in ancient China that a piece of lodestone free to turn would point out a fixed direction, and direction-finding devices based on it were in use there long before they reached Europe. By about a thousand years ago, Chinese sailors were using such devices to hold a course at sea.

Because these pieces were dug out of the earth just as they were, they are called natural magnets. Our word ‘magnet’ comes from Magnesia, the place the first pieces came from.

10.1.2 Artificial Magnets And Their Shapes

Natural magnets are of little practical use. They come in irregular, odd shapes that cannot be fitted into an instrument, and they are simply not strong enough magnetically for most jobs.

So magnets are instead manufactured from iron and steel in whatever shape the work demands. A magnet made in this way is called an artificial magnet. The common shapes are drawn in Fig. 10.1-1.

Diagram

Fig. 10.1-1 — Common Shapes Of Artificial Magnets Four separate labelled sketches in a row. (a) A straight rectangular bar with N marked at one end and S at the other, labelled ‘bar magnet’. (b) A U-shaped magnet with N on one arm-end and S on the other, labelled ‘horse shoe magnet’. (c) A slim diamond-shaped needle balanced on a sharp vertical pivot, one half shaded and marked N, the other marked S, labelled ‘magnetic needle’. (d) A small circular box with a glass top, a pivoted needle inside, and the letters N, E, S, W printed on a dial, labelled ‘magnetic compass’.

A bar magnet is a straight rectangular bar, and a horse shoe magnet is bent into a U so that both its poles face the same way. A magnetic needle is a slender magnet balanced on a sharp pivot so that it can swing freely in a horizontal plane. Mount that needle in a small box over a printed dial and you have a magnetic compass.

Steel and soft iron are both used to make artificial magnets, but for different jobs. Steel is hard to magnetise and hard to demagnetise, so it is used where the magnetism must last. Soft iron magnetises easily but loses it again just as easily.

10.1.3 The Directive Property Of A Freely Suspended Magnet

Tie a bar magnet at its middle with a silk thread and hang it so that it is free to turn in a horizontal plane. Give it a push. It swings to and fro, slows down, and finally comes to rest — and it always comes to rest pointing along the geographic north–south direction, as shown in Fig. 10.1-2.

Diagram

Fig. 10.1-2 — A Freely Suspended Magnet Sets Itself North–South A bar magnet hung horizontally at its mid-point from a silk thread tied to a fixed rigid support drawn at the top; label the thread ‘silk thread’. Mark the two ends of the magnet N and S. Beside the magnet draw a horizontal reference arrow labelled at its two ends ‘geographic north’ and ‘geographic south’, drawn parallel to the length of the magnet to show that the magnet has set itself along this line.

Silk thread is chosen deliberately, because it is untwisted and offers almost no resistance to turning. The magnet is therefore free to take up whatever direction it prefers, and it prefers north–south. This behaviour of a freely suspended magnet is called its directive property.

The two ends of a magnet are called its poles, and this is how they get their names. The end that turns towards the geographic north is the north-seeking pole, shortened in use to the north pole of the magnet. The other end is the south pole.

Picking Out The Magnetised Bar

1. What is given, and what is asked — two bars that look exactly alike; one of them is a magnet and the other is an unmagnetised bar of the same material. Neither may be tested against a third magnet. We must decide which one is the magnet.

  1. The property used — only a magnet has the directive property. A magnet free to turn in a horizontal plane comes to rest along the geographic north–south direction, while an unmagnetised bar has no preferred direction at all.

  2. The working — hang the first bar by its middle from a silk thread so that it can swing freely in a horizontal plane. Set it swinging and wait until it stops. Note the direction in which it settles. Displace it gently and let it settle a second time. Repeat the whole test with the second bar.

  3. The answer — the bar that settles along the north–south direction every time is the magnetised bar. The bar that comes to rest in a different direction each time is the unmagnetised one. The result is sensible, because an unmagnetised bar is not acted on by anything that would favour one horizontal direction over another.

Push a small sewing needle through a flat piece of cork or thermocol and float it in a wide bowl of still water. Now stroke the needle a few times, always in the same direction, with one end of a magnet. Float it again and watch which way it settles.

10.1.4 Attraction And Repulsion Between Poles

Now bring a second magnet slowly up to a freely suspended one and watch what its ends do. The behaviour depends entirely on which pair of poles you bring together, and it is shown in Fig. 10.1-3.

Diagram

Fig. 10.1-3 — Like Poles Repel, Unlike Poles Attract Three labelled pairs of bar magnets drawn one below the other, each pair placed end to end with a small gap. (a) N of the left magnet facing N of the right magnet, with two arrows pointing away from the gap, labelled ‘repulsion’. (b) S facing S, with two arrows pointing away from the gap, labelled ‘repulsion’. (c) N facing S, with two arrows pointing towards the gap, labelled ‘attraction’.

Bring two north poles together and they push each other apart. Bring two south poles together and they also push each other apart. But bring a north pole up to a south pole and they pull towards each other.

NotePrinciple / Law

The Law Of Magnetic Poles Two like poles — both north or both south — repel each other, while two unlike poles — one north and one south — attract each other.

This law is what makes a compass needle useful. Its north pole is pulled one way and its south pole the other, so the needle as a whole turns until it lies along a definite direction and then stays there.

Finding Your Way With A Compass A hiker’s compass is a magnetic needle floating in a fluid-filled capsule over a marked dial. The fluid damps the swinging so the needle settles in a second or two instead of oscillating for a minute. To use it, you turn the whole instrument until the needle’s north end lies over the N mark on the dial; every other direction on the dial is then correct, and a bearing can be read off directly. This is why a compass must be kept away from iron objects, loudspeakers and phone magnets — anything magnetic close by will pull the needle off its true setting.

Marking The Polarity Of An Unmarked Bar

1. What is given, and what is asked — a magnetised bar whose ends carry no markings, and a compass needle whose north pole is already known. We must decide which end of the bar is its north pole.

  1. The principle used — the law of magnetic poles. Like poles repel and unlike poles attract, so the way the compass needle responds tells us which pole of the bar is facing it.

  2. The working — bring one end of the bar slowly up to the north pole of the compass needle and watch. Then turn the bar round and bring its other end up to the same north pole of the needle in the same way.

  3. The answer — the end of the bar that drives the north pole of the needle away is the north pole of the bar, because only two like poles repel. The end that draws the north pole of the needle towards it is the south pole of the bar. Note that repulsion is the surer test of the two: a plain unmagnetised iron bar would also attract the needle, but nothing except a magnetic pole can repel it.

A bar magnet is suspended freely and allowed to come to rest. The end of it that points towards the geographic north is then brought close to one end of a second freely suspended magnet, and the two ends move apart from each other. State the polarity of that end of the second magnet, and give your reasoning.

10.2 Induced Magnetism

10.2.1 Magnetic Induction And Induced Magnetism

Take an unmagnetised bar \(AB\) made of a magnetic material — a material such as soft iron or steel, which a magnet can attract and which can itself be turned into a magnet. On its own the bar does nothing. Sprinkle iron filings near its ends and none of them cling to it.

Now place a magnet close to the bar, or in contact with it, as in Fig. 10.2-1(a), and repeat the test. This time the filings cling to both ends of the bar. The bar has become a magnet.

Diagram

Fig. 10.2-1 — A Bar Becomes A Magnet While A Magnet Is Near It Two labelled sketches, one below the other. (a) A bar magnet drawn horizontally on the left with N at its left end and S at its right end, labelled ‘magnet’; immediately to its right, in line with it and just touching, a plain rectangular bar labelled ‘iron or steel bar’ with A at its left end and B at its right end; small induced letters n at end A and s at end B; a bushy cluster of iron filings drawn clinging to end A and another cluster clinging to end B, labelled ‘iron filings’; caption line inside the figure ‘iron filings cling to the bar in the presence of the magnet’. (b) The same plain bar AB alone with the magnet removed, and the iron filings drawn as a loose heap lying on the table below the bar; caption line inside the figure ‘the filings fall off when the magnet is taken away’.

Take the magnet away and test the bar once more. Nearly all the filings that were clinging to it now fall off, as in Fig. 10.2-1(b). The bar has lost its magnetism again.

So a bar of a magnetic material behaves like a magnet only so long as it is kept near, or in contact with, a magnet. The magnetism it gains in this way is called induced magnetism, and the process that produces it is called magnetic induction.

NoteDefinition

Induced Magnetism The temporary magnetism acquired by a magnetic material when it is kept near, or in contact with, a magnet is called induced magnetism.

NoteDefinition

Magnetic Induction The process by which a piece of magnetic material acquires magnetic properties temporarily in the presence of another magnet near it is called magnetic induction.

Notice that nothing has to touch for this to happen. The bar becomes a magnet even when the magnet is merely brought near it, without contact.

Q. If the bar AB really is a magnet while the magnet lies beside it, why do the filings drop the moment the magnet is taken away?

A. Because the bar’s magnetism was never its own. It is borrowed, and it lasts only while the magnet is close by. Once the magnet goes, the bar stops being a magnet and has nothing left to hold the filings with.

Collect a steel spoon, a piece of aluminium foil, a length of copper wire, a brass key and an iron nail. Hold a magnet close to each in turn and sort them into two piles — those that are pulled towards it and those that are not. The first pile is your set of magnetic materials.

10.2.2 Polarity Developed On The Induced Magnet

The bar \(AB\) is now a magnet, so it must have a north pole and a south pole. Which end is which? Bring a compass needle up to each end in turn and read off the polarity from the way the needle responds, as shown in Fig. 10.2-2.

Diagram

Fig. 10.2-2 — Testing The Induced Polarity With A Compass Needle A bar magnet on the left with N at its left end and S at its right end, and immediately to its right a plain bar with A at its near (left) end and B at its far (right) end. A small pivoted compass needle is drawn just beyond end A and a second one just beyond end B. The needle near A is drawn with its own S end turned towards A; the needle near B is drawn with its own N end turned towards B. Mark the induced polarity as n at A and s at B, and label the whole ‘the near end becomes the opposite pole, the far end the same pole’.

In Fig. 10.2-2 the south pole of the magnet faces end \(A\) of the bar. The test shows that end \(A\) becomes a north pole — the opposite of the pole facing it. End \(B\), at the far side, becomes a south pole — the same as the pole facing \(A\).

NotePrinciple / Law

The Rule Of Induced Polarity A magnetic pole induces an opposite polarity on the near end of the iron bar and a similar polarity on its farther end.

The rule works whichever pole of the magnet is presented. Turn the magnet round so that its north pole faces \(A\), and \(A\) becomes a south pole while \(B\) becomes a north pole.

Induced magnetism and permanent magnetism. Induced magnetism is borrowed from a magnet standing nearby, and it goes when that magnet goes. A permanent magnet keeps its magnetism with nothing else near it at all.

10.2.3 Induction Precedes Attraction

We can now answer a question that has been waiting since the start of the chapter: why is an ordinary, unmagnetised piece of iron attracted to a magnet at all? An unmagnetised piece has no poles, and there is nothing for the magnet to pull on.

The answer is that it does not stay unmagnetised. As the magnet comes near, the nearer end of the iron acquires the opposite polarity by magnetic induction. That end and the pole of the magnet facing it are now unlike poles.

Unlike poles attract, so the iron is drawn towards the magnet. The iron first becomes a magnet by induction, and only then is it attracted. In short, induction precedes attraction.

Two Iron Needles Hung From A Horse Shoe Magnet

1. What is given, and what is asked — a horse shoe magnet with a north pole at the end of one arm and a south pole at the end of the other. A small iron needle hangs from each pole by its upper end, as in Fig. 10.2-3. We must find the polarity of each end of each needle, and say how the two lower ends behave.

  1. The principle used — the rule of induced polarity, since each needle is unmagnetised iron held against a pole. The near end takes the opposite polarity and the far end the same polarity. The law of magnetic poles then settles what the free lower ends do to each other.

  2. The working — the first needle touches the north pole of the magnet, so its upper end becomes a south pole and its lower end a north pole. The second needle touches the south pole, so its upper end becomes a north pole and its lower end a south pole. The two lower ends are therefore a north pole and a south pole facing each other.

  3. The answer — the lower ends carry unlike polarities, so they attract and swing towards each other, as the figure shows. The result is sensible: had both needles hung from the same pole of a magnet, both lower ends would have carried the same polarity and would have swung apart instead.

Diagram

Fig. 10.2-3 — Iron Needles Hanging From The Poles Of A Horse Shoe Magnet A U-shaped horse shoe magnet drawn with its two arm-ends pointing downwards, N marked on the left arm-end and S on the right arm-end. A thin straight iron needle hangs from each arm-end, touching it at the needle’s upper end. On the left needle mark s at the top and n at the bottom; on the right needle mark n at the top and s at the bottom. Draw the two needles tilted so that their lower tips lean in towards each other, with a small arrow on each tip pointing inwards.

10.2.4 Induced Magnetism Is Temporary

Hold one pole of a bar magnet just above a heap of small iron nails. A nail jumps up and clings to the pole — and then a second nail clings to the first, a third to the second, and so on. A hanging chain of nails forms, as shown in Fig. 10.2-4.

Diagram

Fig. 10.2-4 — A Chain Of Iron Nails Hanging From One Pole Of A Bar Magnet A bar magnet drawn horizontally with S at its left end and N at its right end. Hanging vertically from the N end, a chain of four or five iron nails drawn one below the other, each nail’s head touching the tip of the nail above it. On every nail mark the induced polarity: s at its upper end and n at its lower end. Label the chain ‘each nail is magnetised by the nail above it’.

The chain forms by induction, one link at a time. The magnet magnetises the first nail, which is therefore attracted and clings to it. That first nail is now a magnet, so it magnetises the second nail and attracts it, and the second magnetises the third.

The chain does not grow for ever. It stops when the force with which the magnet attracts the first nail is just enough to balance the total weight of all the nails hanging below it. Add one more nail and the chain cannot hold it.

Now hold the topmost nail steady between your fingers and slide the magnet away. Every nail in the chain falls. The topmost nail loses its magnetism the moment the magnet is removed, so the nail below it loses its magnetism too, and so on down the chain. With nothing left to hold them together, they separate and fall under gravity.

This is the clearest evidence that magnetism acquired by induction is purely temporary. It lasts only as long as the magnet causing the induction stays in the neighbourhood.

Q2. An iron nail is not a magnet, yet it clings to a magnet and can even hold a second nail hanging below it. Where does the nail get its magnetism from, and why does it lose it so quickly?

A. The nail gets it from the magnet itself, by magnetic induction. While the magnet is near, the nail becomes a magnet with poles of its own, so it can attract a second nail below it. This magnetism is only borrowed, so the instant the magnet is taken away the nail stops being a magnet and the chain falls apart.

Why A Screwdriver Holds Its Screw A steel screw brought up to a magnetised screwdriver tip becomes a magnet by induction, with the pole opposite to the tip forming on the end nearest it. Unlike poles attract, so the screw sticks to the tip and can be carried into an awkward corner one-handed. Workshops use the same effect in a magnetic tool strip on the wall: spanners and chisels hang from it by induced magnetism and drop off freely when pulled away. Steel, unlike soft iron, does keep a little of its magnetism afterwards — which is why tools stored on such a strip slowly become weakly magnetic themselves and start picking up filings.

Several soft iron pins hang in a chain from the south pole of a bar magnet. Draw the chain and mark the polarity at both ends of each pin. Then state, with a reason, what you would see if a compass needle were brought up to the lowest end of the chain.

10.3 Lines Of Magnetic Field

10.3.1 The Magnetic Field Of A Magnet

Place a magnetic compass by itself on a table, well away from anything magnetic. Its needle settles along the geographic north–south direction. It does this because the earth itself has a magnetic field, which is taken up later in this chapter.

Now bring a magnet near the compass. The needle swings round and comes to rest pointing some other way altogether. Move the compass to a different place around the magnet and the needle takes up yet another direction, as Fig. 10.3-1 shows.

Diagram

Fig. 10.3-1 — A Compass Needle At Different Points Around A Bar Magnet A bar magnet drawn horizontally in the centre with N at its right end and S at its left end. Six small pivoted compass needles drawn at different points around it — one beyond the N end, one beyond the S end, two above the magnet and two below it — each needle drawn tilted at a different angle, and in every case with its own N end turned towards the nearer pole of the bar magnet. Draw a dotted line to one side labelled ‘geographic north–south direction’ for comparison, and label the whole ‘the needle rests in a different direction at each point’.

Wherever the compass is put, the needle turns so that one of its ends points towards the nearer pole of the magnet. The needle behaves this way because the magnet is influencing the space around it. The region in which this influence is felt is called the magnetic field of the magnet.

NoteDefinition

Magnetic Field The space around a magnet in which the needle of a compass rests in a direction other than the geographic north–south direction is called the magnetic field of the magnet.

Carry the compass further and further away and the effect weakens. At a large enough distance the needle swings back to the geographic north–south direction, because the magnet’s influence there is too feeble to matter. The magnetic field of a magnet grows weaker as the distance from the magnet increases.

Put a small compass on a table and let it settle. Now slide a fridge magnet slowly towards it along the table, stopping every few centimetres. Note how far away the magnet has to be before the needle stops taking any notice of it.

10.3.2 Magnetic Field As A Vector Quantity

Magnetic field is a vector quantity, which means it has both a magnitude and a direction, and both have to be stated before the field at a point is fully described.

Its magnitude is judged by the force felt by a magnetic pole of unit strength placed at that point. A stronger field means a bigger force on the same pole, so the force is a fair measure of how strong the field is.

Its direction at a point is simply the direction in which the north pole of a compass needle rests when the needle is placed at that point.

Magnetic field. SI unit: the tesla (T). Direction convention: the direction of the field at a point is the direction in which the north pole of a compass needle placed there comes to rest — never the direction of the south pole.

10.3.3 The Pattern Made By Iron Filings

The compass tells us the field direction at one point at a time, which is slow work. Iron filings show the whole pattern at once.

Lay a bar magnet on a table and place a sheet of stiff paper or a glass plate over it. Sprinkle iron filings uniformly over the plate, then tap the plate gently. The filings shift and settle themselves along a set of curved lines, as in Fig. 10.3-2.

Diagram

Fig. 10.3-2 — Iron Filings Settling Into A Pattern Over A Bar Magnet A rectangular bar magnet seen from above, drawn in outline in the centre with N at its right end and S at its left end, lying beneath a plate. All around it, hundreds of short dashes representing iron filings, arranged end to end along smooth curves that leave the N end, arc outwards above and below the magnet, and return to the S end. Draw the dashes packed densely close to the two ends and sparsely near the middle of the magnet and far from it. Label ‘iron filings sprinkled on the glass plate’.

The reason the filings line up is magnetic induction, which we met in the previous section. Each tiny filing becomes a little magnet in the field of the bar magnet, and each little magnet then experiences a force that turns it. Tapping the plate frees the filings for a moment from friction so that they can swing round and take up their preferred direction.

The curved lines the filings pick out are called magnetic field lines.

Faraday And The Idea Of Lines Of Force In the 1830s Michael Faraday, working at the Royal Institution in London, spent a great deal of time scattering iron filings around magnets and watching the patterns they made. Most physicists of his day thought of magnetism as one magnet reaching across empty space to pull at another. Faraday looked at the filing patterns and saw something different — lines threading the whole space around the magnet, which he called lines of force. He treated them as real, and used them to reason about magnets and currents even though he had almost no mathematical training. The idea proved to be one of the most fruitful in physics, and it is the picture every field diagram in this chapter is built on.

10.3.4 Magnetic Field Lines And Their Direction

Place a compass needle at any point in a magnetic field and it rests along the field line passing through that point. The needle is, in effect, a short piece of the line made visible.

This gives us a way of putting a direction on the line. An arrow is marked on the field line running from the south pole of the needle towards its north pole. That arrow gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point, and it is drawn in Fig. 10.3-3.

Diagram

Fig. 10.3-3 — Reading The Direction Of A Field Line A single smooth curve drawn across the figure, labelled ‘magnetic field line’. A small compass needle drawn lying along the curve at a point P, with its S end and N end marked, and its length lying along the curve. An arrowhead drawn on the curve at P pointing from the needle’s S end towards its N end, labelled ‘direction of the magnetic field at P’. A straight dashed line drawn touching the curve at P and nowhere else, labelled ‘tangent at P’.

The line itself is curved, but at any one point it has a definite direction — the direction of the tangent drawn to it at that point. This is what lets a curved line carry direction information.

NoteDefinition

Magnetic Field Line A magnetic field line is a continuous curve in a magnetic field such that the tangent at any point of the curve gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point.

The magnetic field and the magnetic field lines. The field exists everywhere in the space around a magnet, whether anything is drawn or not. The lines are our way of picturing that field on paper, and we draw as few or as many of them as we find convenient.

10.4 Properties Of Magnetic Field Lines

Field lines are not drawn at random. They follow a set of rules, and once you know the rules you can read a field diagram — or catch a wrong one. The magnetic field lines have the following seven properties.

How The Lines Run
  1. They are closed and continuous curves.
  2. Outside the magnet, they are directed from the north pole towards the south pole.
  3. The tangent at any point on a field line gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point.

Outside the magnet a line leaves the north pole, sweeps round and arrives at the south pole. It does not stop there. Inside the magnet the same line continues from the south pole back to the north pole, so it closes on itself and forms a complete loop with no free ends. This is what property 1 means, and it is drawn in Fig. 10.4-1.

Diagram

Fig. 10.4-1 — Field Lines Of A Bar Magnet Form Closed Curves A bar magnet drawn in outline in the centre, seen from above, with N at its right end and S at its left end. Several smooth closed loops drawn around it: each loop leaves the N end, arcs outwards, curves round and enters the S end, and is then continued as a dashed line straight through the inside of the magnet from S back to N. Arrowheads on every loop point away from N outside the magnet and from S towards N inside it. Draw the loops packed close together at the two ends and spread widely apart opposite the middle of the magnet. Label one point close to the N end as X and one point well out to the side of the middle of the magnet as Y.

Property 3 we have already met. Because the line is curved, its direction at a point is the direction of the tangent drawn to the curve at that point, and that is the direction of the field there.

Field Lines Never Cross
  1. They never intersect one another.

Suppose two field lines \(PQ\) and \(PR\) did cross at a point \(P\), as drawn in Fig. 10.4-2. A compass needle placed at \(P\) would have to rest along \(PQ\), because a needle always lies along a field line. It would also have to rest along \(PR\), for the same reason.

Diagram

Fig. 10.4-2 — Two Field Lines Cannot Intersect Two smooth curves drawn crossing each other at a single point, which is labelled P. The upper curve carries an arrowhead at its far end, which is labelled Q; the lower curve carries an arrowhead at its far end, which is labelled R. A small compass needle drawn at P, sketched twice in faint outline — once lying along PQ and once lying along PR — with a question mark beside it and the label ‘the needle cannot point two ways at once’.

The needle cannot point in two directions at the same time. That would mean the magnetic field at \(P\) had two directions at once, which is impossible. So two field lines never intersect.

Q3. Two magnetic field lines may run very close together, but they never cross. What would go wrong if two of them did cross at a point?

A. At the crossing point the field would have two directions at the same time. A compass needle placed there lies along the field line through it, so it would have to lie along both lines at once — which no needle can do. Since the magnetic field at any point has one definite direction, two field lines can never intersect.

Spacing Shows Strength
  1. They are crowded near the poles of the magnet, where the magnetic field is strong, and are far apart near the middle of the magnet and far from the magnet, where the magnetic field is weak.
  2. Parallel and equidistant field lines represent a uniform magnetic field. The earth’s magnetic field in a limited space is uniform.

Look again at Fig. 10.4-1. The lines are packed tightly at the two ends and spread out opposite the middle. Wherever they are crowded, the field is strong; wherever they are spread out, it is weak. So the spacing of a field diagram is not decoration — it is a reading of the field’s strength.

A uniform magnetic field is one that has the same magnitude and the same direction at every point in the region concerned. Since the direction is everywhere the same, the lines must be parallel, and since the strength is everywhere the same, they must be equally spaced. Fig. 10.4-3 shows what such a field looks like.

Diagram

Fig. 10.4-3 — Field Lines Of A Uniform Magnetic Field Five straight vertical lines drawn parallel to one another and exactly equally spaced, each carrying an arrowhead pointing upwards. Label the top of the figure ‘geographic north’ and the bottom ‘geographic south’. Add the label ‘parallel and equidistant lines — a uniform field’ below the figure.

A uniform field and a non-uniform field. In a uniform field the lines are straight, parallel and equally spaced, so the field is the same everywhere. In a non-uniform field the lines curve and their spacing changes, so both the strength and the direction differ from point to point.

Comparing The Field At Two Points From A Diagram

1. What is given, and what is asked — the field pattern of a bar magnet drawn in Fig. 10.4-1. Point X lies close to the north pole, where the lines are packed tightly together. Point Y lies well out to the side, opposite the middle of the magnet, where the lines are widely spaced. We must say at which point the magnetic field is stronger.

  1. The property used — property 5. The field lines are crowded where the field is strong and far apart where it is weak, so the spacing of the lines is a direct measure of the field strength.

  2. The working — count the spacing rather than the lines. At X the lines run close together, showing a large field strength. At Y the same lines have spread far apart, showing a small field strength.

  3. The answer — the magnetic field is stronger at X than at Y. This is physically sensible, because X is near a pole, and we already know that the field of a magnet is strongest at its poles and grows weaker as the distance from the magnet increases.

Field Lines Under Tension
  1. They behave like stretched elastic rubber strings.

A stretched rubber string does two things: it tries to shorten along its own length, and it pushes sideways against any string lying alongside it. Field lines behave in just this way, and that single picture accounts for a great deal of what magnets do.

When a north pole faces a south pole, field lines run across from one to the other. Those lines try to shorten, and so the two poles are pulled together. When two like poles face each other, the lines from each are forced side by side, they push each other apart, and so the two poles are driven apart.

A student draws the field pattern of a bar magnet and shows two of the lines meeting at a point some distance beyond the north pole. State what is wrong with the diagram, and give the reason. Then state whether the lines drawn near the middle of the magnet should be closer together or further apart than those drawn near its ends.

10.5 Magnetic Field Of The Earth

10.5.1 Evidences Of The Earth’s Magnetic Field

The earth itself has a magnetic field, and behaves like a magnet. Nobody can dig down and look, so the claim has to be built up from evidence at the surface. Four pieces of evidence point to it.

A Freely Suspended Needle Rests North–South

When a magnetic needle, or a magnet, is suspended so that it is free to turn in a horizontal plane, it always comes to rest indicating the geographic north–south direction.

Now think about what that requires. The north pole of a magnet will turn towards the geographic north only if there is a magnetic south pole up there attracting it, since unlike poles attract. In the same way, its south pole will turn towards the geographic south only if there is a magnetic north pole down there.

So we are forced to assume that there is a magnet inside the earth, with its south pole in the geographic north and its north pole in the geographic south.

Q1. A magnet hung from a thread swings for a while and then stops — and it always stops pointing the same way. Why should one particular direction be special?

A. Because the earth is itself a magnet, and the space around us is filled with its magnetic field. The suspended magnet turns until it lies along that field, just as a compass needle does. The north–south line is not special to the room; it is special to the earth.

Q4. If the Earth really behaves like a huge magnet, which kind of magnetic pole must lie near the geographic north — and how could you work that out from a compass alone?

A. A magnetic south pole must lie near the geographic north. The reasoning needs nothing more than the compass: its north pole turns towards the geographic north, and a north pole is attracted only by a south pole. So whatever lies in that direction inside the earth must be a magnetic south pole.

An Iron Rod Buried North–South Becomes A Magnet

If an iron rod is buried a few metres inside the earth and kept along the north–south direction, it is found after some days that the rod has become a weak magnet.

Nothing has touched it and no magnet has been brought near it, so the magnetism must have been induced by something already present in that space. This is possible only if the earth itself behaves like a magnet.

Neutral Points Appear When Field Lines Are Plotted

Place a bar magnet on a horizontal plane with its north pole facing the geographic north and plot the field lines around it. Two points are found, one on either side of the magnet on its broad side-on position, at which the resultant magnetic field is zero. A compass needle placed at such a point rests in any direction at all. These are called neutral points — points at which the net magnetic field is zero.

Place the magnet the other way round, with its north pole facing the geographic south, and again two such points appear, one on either side of the magnet, this time on its end-on position.

Now, the magnet certainly has a field of its own at those points. For the resultant to be zero, some other field must be present there, equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, cancelling it exactly. That other field is the horizontal component of the earth’s magnetic field. Neutral points are taken up in full in Section 10.8.

A Needle Rests At Different Angles In Different Places

Suspend a magnetic needle so that it is free to turn in a vertical plane, and carry it around the earth passing over the geographic poles. Its geometric axis makes a different angle with the horizontal at different places, as Fig. 10.5-1 shows.

Diagram

Fig. 10.5-1 — Inclination Of A Magnetic Needle At Different Places On The Earth’s Surface A circle representing the earth, with the outlines of the continents drawn lightly inside it; where India is shown, draw it to the full extent of its territory as officially defined by the Government of India, including Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh. Mark ‘geographic N pole’ at the top and ‘geographic S pole’ at the bottom, and draw the geographic equator as a horizontal line across the middle, labelled. Draw a tilted line through the centre of the circle, inclined at a small angle to the vertical, with ‘magnetic S pole’ marked where it meets the surface in the north and ‘magnetic N pole’ where it meets the surface in the south; label the line ‘magnetic axis’. Draw a tilted circle at right angles to this axis and label it ‘magnetic equator’. Around the outside of the earth, place about ten small magnetic needles drawn as short arrows: standing exactly perpendicular to the surface at the two magnetic poles, lying exactly along the surface at two points on the magnetic equator, and inclined at gradually increasing angles to the surface at the points between.

At two places the needle becomes normal to the earth’s surface — it stands vertical. At two other places it becomes parallel to the earth’s surface — it lies horizontal. Everywhere else it rests at some angle in between. A needle could only behave in this orderly way if the earth had a magnetic field of its own.

10.5.2 Magnetic Poles And The Magnetic Equator

The two special sets of places found in the last experiment are given names.

NoteDefinition

Magnetic Poles Of The Earth The two places where a magnetic needle, free to turn in a vertical plane, becomes vertical are called the magnetic poles of the earth.

NoteDefinition

Magnetic Equator The line joining the places where such a magnetic needle becomes horizontal is called the magnetic equator.

The geographic poles and the magnetic poles. The geographic poles are the two ends of the axis about which the earth spins. The magnetic poles are where a dip needle stands vertical. They lie near each other, but they are not at the same place.

How A Dip Needle Behaves On A Journey North

1. What is given, and what is asked — a magnetic needle free to turn in a vertical plane is carried slowly from a place on the magnetic equator towards the earth’s magnetic pole in the north. We must describe how the angle it makes with the horizontal changes along the way, and what it does at the end.

  1. The property used — the behaviour set out in evidence (iv) and drawn in Fig. 10.5-1. The needle rests along the earth’s magnetic field, and that field lies along the surface at the magnetic equator and runs at right angles to the surface at the magnetic poles.

  2. The working — at the starting point, on the magnetic equator, the needle lies horizontal, so the angle with the horizontal is \(0^\\circ\). As the journey proceeds northwards the field becomes more and more steeply inclined to the surface, and the needle follows it, tilting further from the horizontal at every stage.

  3. The answer — the angle grows steadily from \(0^\\circ\) at the magnetic equator until, at the magnetic pole, the needle stands vertical and the angle is \(90^\\circ\). The result is sensible, since standing vertical is exactly the test by which the magnetic pole was defined in the first place.

10.5.3 The Earth As A Huge Bar Magnet

Putting the four pieces of evidence together, we can draw a conclusion. The earth behaves as if a huge bar magnet were placed at its centre, with its magnetic south pole in the geographic north and its magnetic north pole in the geographic south. This picture is drawn in Fig. 10.5-2.

Diagram

Fig. 10.5-2 — The Earth Behaves Like A Huge Bar Magnet At Its Centre A circle representing the earth with ‘geographic N pole’ at the top and ‘geographic S pole’ at the bottom, and a vertical dashed line through the centre labelled ‘axis of rotation’. Inside the circle, a short bar magnet drawn at the centre and tilted from the vertical, with its S end towards the geographic north and its N end towards the geographic south. Extend the length of this magnet as a dashed line to the surface at both ends and label it ‘magnetic axis’; mark the angle between the magnetic axis and the axis of rotation as 17°. Draw the field lines of the bar magnet looping outside the earth, with arrowheads showing them running from the magnetic north pole region in the south, round the outside, to the magnetic south pole region in the north.

The two sets of poles do not coincide. The geographic poles are fixed by the earth’s spin, the magnetic poles by its magnetism, and the two are somewhat displaced from each other. The magnetic axis of the earth — the line joining its magnetic poles — makes an angle of \(17^\\circ\) with the axis of rotation.

The magnetic south pole of the earth is in Canada, roughly two thousand kilometres away from the geographic north pole, at \(70.75^\\circ\) north latitude and \(96^\\circ\) west longitude. The earth’s magnetic north pole lies a comparable distance from the geographic south pole, at \(73^\\circ\) south latitude and \(155^\\circ\) east longitude.

These positions are not fixed. It has been observed experimentally that the magnetic poles do not stay still, but gradually change their positions over long periods of time.

The earth’s magnetic field reaches far out into space, where it deflects the stream of charged particles arriving from the sun. Some of these particles are funnelled down towards the polar regions, where they make the upper atmosphere glow. That glow is the aurora.

Navigating By The Earth’s Field Migrating birds cross thousands of kilometres of unfamiliar ground, often at night and over open sea, and experiments have shown that several species use the earth’s magnetic field among their cues for holding a course. Ships and aircraft do the same thing with instruments. A magnetic compass on board must be corrected before it can be trusted, because the vessel’s own steel hull becomes magnetised by induction in the earth’s field and pulls the needle off true. Small correcting magnets and iron spheres are fitted around the compass to cancel this effect — a procedure called swinging the compass, carried out whenever a ship is refitted.

10.5.4 Magnetic Field Lines Of The Earth

Over the whole planet the earth’s field lines curve, as Fig. 10.5-2 shows. But over a small region — a table top, a laboratory bench — the curvature is far too slight to notice. Within such a limited space the field lines of the earth are parallel to one another and equidistant, exactly the pattern drawn in Fig. 10.4-3. The earth’s magnetic field in a limited space is therefore uniform.

These lines are always directed from the geographic south towards the geographic north. That is the direction in which a freely suspended needle sets itself, and it is the reason the north pole of a compass needle points north.

Their angle to the ground changes with place. They are horizontal at the magnetic equator and vertical at the magnetic poles, and at every other point they are inclined to the horizontal.

NotePrinciple / Law

Direction Of The Earth’s Field Lines At The Surface The magnetic field lines of the earth are normal to the earth’s surface near the magnetic poles and parallel to the earth’s surface near the magnetic equator.

Stand in the middle of a room, away from steel almirahs and electrical fittings, and let a compass settle. Mark the north–south line on the floor with two slips of paper. Now repeat the test standing close to a steel cupboard and see whether the line you get is the same.

10.6 Plotting The Uniform Magnetic Field Lines Of The Earth

We have said that the earth’s magnetic field is uniform in a limited space. That is a claim about the world, and it can be checked on a table top with nothing more than a compass needle and a pencil. The method below traces the earth’s field lines one at a time.

The Experiment

Fix a sheet of paper on a drawing board, or on a table top, using brass pins. Brass is chosen deliberately, because it is not a magnetic material and so cannot disturb the field being plotted. For the same reason the board must be well away from magnets, iron objects and electrical fittings.

Place a small compass needle on the paper at position 1, as in Fig. 10.6-1(a). The compass must be small, so that the field does not change appreciably from one end of the needle to the other.

Diagram

Fig. 10.6-1 — Tracing A Field Line Of The Earth With A Compass Needle Two labelled parts side by side. (a) A sheet of paper pinned at its corners, with a small circular compass drawn three times, one above the other, marked position 1, position 2 and position 3, each with its needle marked N at the upper end and S at the lower end; a pencil dot marked just beyond each end of the needle at every position, with the dot in front of the N end of position 1 coinciding exactly with the S end of the needle at position 2, and the dot in front of the N end of position 2 coinciding with the S end at position 3. (b) The same dots joined by a single straight line carrying an arrowhead pointing from the S end towards the N end, labelled ‘one magnetic field line of the earth’. Label the pins ‘brass pins’.

Look down from directly above the needle and mark two pencil dots on the paper, exactly in front of the two ends of the needle. Now move the compass to position 2 in such a way that one end of the needle sits on the second pencil dot. Mark the position of its other end with a fresh dot.

Repeat this, moving the compass to positions 3, 4 and so on, until several dots have been marked across the sheet. Join the dots. You get a straight line, and that line is one magnetic field line of the earth.

Flowchart

FC 10.1 — Plotting One Field Line Of The Earth Pin the paper down with brass pins → place the small compass at position 1 → mark a pencil dot in front of each end of the needle → move the compass so that one end of the needle rests on the second dot → mark a dot in front of the other end → repeat for positions 3, 4, 5 … across the sheet → join all the dots → mark an arrow on the line from the S end of the needle towards its N end

Now start again from a different point on the paper and trace out a second line in the same way. Draw several lines in this manner, each begun at a different starting point.

Finally, label each line with an arrow drawn from the south pole of the needle towards its north pole. The arrow shows the direction of the magnetic field along that line.

Always mark the dots looking straight down at the needle, never from one side. Viewed from the side, the dot lands slightly off the true position of the needle’s end, and that small error is repeated at every step until the traced line bends away from the truth.

What The Plotted Lines Show

The set of lines obtained is drawn in Fig. 10.6-2, and three things are noticed about it.

Diagram

Fig. 10.6-2 — Field Lines Of The Earth Obtained In A Limited Space Five straight lines drawn on a pinned sheet of paper, all vertical, all exactly parallel and equally spaced, each carrying an arrowhead pointing upwards. Mark ‘geographic north’ at the top of the sheet and ‘geographic south’ at the bottom. Label the figure ‘the lines are straight, parallel, equidistant and do not intersect’.

First, the lines do not intersect each other, which is what property 4 of field lines requires. Second, they are parallel and equidistant — and by property 6 that means the field they represent is uniform.

Third, every arrow points the same way, from the geographic south towards the geographic north. This is exactly the direction in which a magnetic needle suspended freely in a horizontal plane comes to rest.

Reading A Plotted Pattern

1. What is given, and what is asked — a student plots field lines on a sheet of paper on a table top and obtains a set of straight lines that are parallel to one another and equally spaced throughout. We must say what kind of field this is, and whether any magnet was lying near the sheet.

  1. The properties used — property 6, that parallel and equidistant lines represent a uniform field, together with property 5, that the lines of a magnet’s field are crowded near its poles and spread out elsewhere.

  2. The working — the spacing is the same everywhere on the sheet, so the field has the same strength at every point. The lines are straight and parallel, so it has the same direction at every point. Neither the crowding nor the curvature that a nearby magnet would produce is present anywhere in the pattern.

  3. The answer — the field is uniform, and it is the earth’s magnetic field alone; no magnet was near the sheet. The answer is sensible, because the earth’s field is uniform over a small region such as a table top.

Plot three or four field lines on a sheet of paper by the method above. Then take a ruler and measure the perpendicular distance between two neighbouring lines at the top of the sheet, at the middle and at the bottom. See how nearly equal your three measurements are.

A student plotting the earth’s field lines uses iron pins instead of brass ones to hold the paper down, and finds that the lines near the corners of the sheet come out curved. Explain what has gone wrong, and state what the curvature of those lines tells you about the field near the corners.

10.7 Plotting The Non-Uniform Field Of A Strong Bar Magnet

The earth’s field over a table top was uniform, and plotting it gave straight, parallel, equally spaced lines. The field around a bar magnet is nothing like that. It is non-uniform.

In a non-uniform magnetic field the lines are neither equispaced nor parallel. They are curved, either converging towards a place or diverging away from one, and their spacing changes from point to point. Where they are closely spaced the field at that place is strong; where they are widely spaced it is weak. Four such patterns are drawn in Fig. 10.7-1.

Diagram

Fig. 10.7-1 — Non-Uniform Magnetic Field Lines Four labelled patterns arranged in two rows. (a) A single bar magnet with N at the right and S at the left, with curved closed lines leaving N, arcing out above and below, and entering S; arrowheads on every line pointing from N to S outside the magnet; caption ‘field lines due to a bar magnet’. (b) A U-shaped horse shoe magnet with N on the left arm-end and S on the right arm-end, with curved lines crossing the gap between the two arm-ends and further lines arcing round the outside; caption ‘field lines due to a horse shoe magnet’. (c) Two bar magnets placed end to end in a line with a gap between them, the left one with S at its left and N at its right, the right one with S at its left and N at its right, so that a north pole faces a south pole across the gap; draw the lines running straight across the gap from the N to the S and bulging outwards on either side; caption ‘field lines due to two unlike poles facing each other’. (d) Two bar magnets placed end to end with a gap, both with N facing the gap; draw the lines from each N curving away sharply from the gap and turning outwards, leaving a clear space in the middle with a small cross marked at the mid-point of the gap; caption ‘field lines due to two like poles facing each other’. Draw the lines closely packed near every pole and widely spaced far from the magnets.

To plot the field of a bar magnet, the magnet is laid along the magnetic meridian — the direction in which a freely suspended magnet comes to rest, which is the geographic north–south direction. Two arrangements are used.

  1. The magnet is placed with its north pole pointing towards the north.
  2. The magnet is placed with its south pole pointing towards the north.

10.7.1 Magnet Placed With Its North Pole Pointing North

Tracing The Lines

Fix a sheet of white paper on a drawing board with brass pins. Place a compass needle in the middle of the paper, let it settle, and mark the north–south direction it gives. Draw a line along this direction.

Lay the bar magnet on the paper along that line, with its north pole pointing towards the north, and mark its outline with a fine pencil. The outline matters, because after the magnet is lifted away you must still know exactly where it stood.

Place the compass needle close to the north pole of the magnet. Looking from directly above, mark two pencil dots exactly in front of the two ends of the needle. Move the needle so that one of its ends coincides with the second dot, and mark the position of the other end with a fresh dot.

Repeat this step by step until the other end of the bar magnet is reached. Join the dots, and this time they give a continuous smooth curve rather than a straight line. That curve is one magnetic field line.

Now repeat the whole process from the same pole of the magnet but starting at a different point, and trace out another line. In this manner draw several field lines, each starting from a different point near the same pole. Label every line with an arrow running from the north pole towards the south pole of the magnet — which is the same as running from the south pole of the compass needle to its north pole.

Reading The Pattern

The lines obtained are shown in Fig. 10.7-2. It is important to be clear about what they represent. They are due to the combined effect of two fields: the magnetic field of the magnet, and the magnetic field of the earth. There is no way to switch the earth off.

Diagram

Fig. 10.7-2 — Field Lines Of A Bar Magnet With Its North Pole N Facing Geographic North A sheet of paper marked ‘north’ at the top and ‘south’ at the bottom, with a small compass rose drawn to one side showing N up, S down, W left and E right. A bar magnet drawn vertically in the centre with N at its upper end and S at its lower end. Around it, several smooth curved field lines with arrowheads, leaving the N end, sweeping outwards to the left and right, and returning to the S end. Well away from the magnet at the top and bottom of the sheet, draw the lines becoming nearly straight, parallel and pointing from south to north. On the horizontal line through the centre of the magnet, mark a cross to the east of the magnet and another cross to the west of it, both at the same distance from the centre, and label them ‘neutral points’.

Two features stand out. First, close to the magnet the lines are strongly curved. In that region the magnet’s own field is much stronger than the earth’s, so it is the magnet that decides the pattern.

As the distance from the magnet increases, the magnet’s field weakens, and at distant points it becomes weaker than the earth’s field. So far from the magnet the lines straighten out and become parallel to each other. There the pattern is due mainly to the earth’s magnetic field.

Second, there are two points equidistant from the centre of the magnet, marked with a cross in Fig. 10.7-2, lying in the east and west directions. At these two points the field of the magnet and the horizontal component of the earth’s field are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction, so they neutralise each other exactly.

These are neutral points. A compass needle placed at one of them is left unaffected and rests in any direction you leave it in. Notice where they lie — out to the side of the magnet, level with its middle, in what is called the broad side-on position.

The field of the magnet and the plotted pattern. What you trace on the paper is never the magnet’s field by itself. It is always the combined result of the magnet’s field and the earth’s field, which is precisely why neutral points can appear at all.

10.7.2 Magnet Placed With Its South Pole Pointing North

Now turn the magnet end for end. It still lies along the magnetic meridian, but this time its south pole points towards the north. The field lines are traced by exactly the same method as before, and the result is shown in Fig. 10.7-3.

Diagram

Fig. 10.7-3 — Field Lines Of A Bar Magnet With Its South Pole Facing Geographic North A sheet of paper marked ‘north’ at the top and ‘south’ at the bottom, with a compass rose to one side showing N up, S down, W left and E right. A bar magnet drawn vertically in the centre with S at its upper end and N at its lower end. Around it, several smooth curved field lines with arrowheads leaving the N end at the bottom, sweeping widely outwards to left and right, and entering the S end at the top. Far from the magnet at the left and right edges of the sheet, draw the lines as nearly straight parallel lines running from south to north. On the vertical line through the magnet, mark a cross directly above the magnet and another directly below it, both at the same distance from the centre, and label them ‘neutral points’.

The first feature is the same as before. Near the magnet the lines are curved, because there the magnet’s field is much stronger than the earth’s. At distant points the magnet’s field has fallen below the earth’s, and the lines become nearly parallel straight lines running from south to north, set by the earth alone.

The second feature has moved. There are again two points equidistant from the centre of the magnet at which the magnet’s field and the horizontal component of the earth’s field are equal and opposite, so that the two fields cancel. But this time they lie in the north and south directions, beyond the two ends of the magnet, in what is called the end-on position. A compass needle placed at either point again comes to rest pointing in any direction.

Table 10.1 — The Two Positions Of The Magnet Compared

Feature North pole pointing north South pole pointing north
Position of the magnet Along the magnetic meridian, N towards geographic north Along the magnetic meridian, S towards geographic north
Where the neutral points lie On the east and west sides of the magnet On the north and south sides of the magnet
Position relative to the magnet Broad side-on, level with the middle of the magnet End-on, beyond the two ends of the magnet
Distance from the centre Equal for both points Equal for both points
Field at a neutral point Zero Zero
Pattern far from the magnet Nearly parallel lines from south to north Nearly parallel lines from south to north

Locating The Neutral Points From The Way A Magnet Is Laid

1. What is given, and what is asked — a bar magnet lies on a table top along the magnetic meridian, with its north pole pointing towards the geographic south. We must say in which directions from the magnet its neutral points lie, and how a compass needle would behave there.

  1. The reasoning used — if the north pole points towards the geographic south, then the south pole points towards the geographic north. This is the second of the two arrangements, drawn in Fig. 10.7-3.

  2. The working — in that arrangement the field of the magnet cancels the horizontal component of the earth’s field along the line through the two ends of the magnet, not to its sides. The neutral points are therefore end-on, one beyond each end, at equal distances from the centre of the magnet.

  3. The answer — the two neutral points lie in the north and south directions from the magnet, equidistant from its centre. A compass needle placed at either of them experiences no resultant magnetic field, so it stays wherever it is put and rests in any direction. This is sensible, since with the magnet reversed its field along the axis now opposes the earth’s field instead of adding to it.

Lay a bar magnet on a table along the north–south line and walk a small compass slowly around it, a few centimetres at a time. Watch how confidently the needle points near the magnet, and how sluggish and undecided it becomes at a couple of places further out.

A bar magnet is placed on a sheet of paper along the magnetic meridian with its north pole facing the geographic north. Sketch four field lines around it, put an arrowhead on each, and mark the likely positions of the neutral points with crosses. State how the spacing of the lines you have drawn changes as you move away from the magnet, and what that change tells you.

10.8 Neutral Points

10.8.1 What A Neutral Point Is

We have met neutral points twice already, once as evidence for the earth’s magnetism and once on the plotting sheet. It is time to state exactly what they are.

A neutral point is not a place where there is no magnetic field being produced. It is a place where two magnetic fields arrive together, equal in magnitude but opposite in direction, so that they cancel and leave nothing behind.

NoteDefinition

Neutral Point A neutral point is a point at which two magnetic fields are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction. The net magnetic field at a neutral point is zero, and a compass needle placed at a neutral point will rest in any direction.

The needle rests in any direction because there is nothing left to turn it. A compass needle is turned by the field it sits in, and at a neutral point the resultant field is zero, so the needle simply stays where it is put.

Q5. Around a bar magnet lying on a table there are two points where a compass needle refuses to settle in any particular direction. What must be happening to the magnetic field there?

A. At those two points the field of the magnet and the horizontal component of the earth’s field are exactly equal in magnitude and exactly opposite in direction, so they cancel. The resultant magnetic field there is zero. With no field to turn it, the needle has no preferred direction and rests wherever it is left. These are the neutral points.

A magnetic pole and a neutral point. At a pole the field is at its strongest and the field lines are most crowded. At a neutral point the field is zero and no field line passes through at all.

The Two Fields That Cancel

The two fields that meet at a neutral point can be produced in either of two ways. They may come from two separate magnets, or one may come from a magnet and the other from the earth.

For the field of a magnet, two facts settle where it points and how strong it is. Outside the magnet it is directed from the north pole towards the south pole, and it decreases as the distance from the magnet increases.

The earth’s magnetic field is resolved into two parts. Its horizontal component is directed from the geographic south to the geographic north. Its vertical component, in the northern hemisphere, points vertically downwards.

It is almost always the horizontal component that does the cancelling on a table top, because a magnet lying flat on the paper has a field that is itself horizontal there.

10.8.2 Positions Of Neutral Points In Different Cases

Where the neutral points appear depends entirely on how the magnet is placed. Four cases cover the arrangements you will meet.

  1. For two magnets at a separation in one line with their like poles facing each other, the neutral point is at some point between the two magnets. This case is drawn in Fig. 10.8-1.
  2. For a magnet standing vertical with its north pole up, the neutral point is at some point on the vertical line away from its north pole, as in Fig. 10.8-2.
  3. If the north pole of the magnet faces the geographic north, the neutral points are situated symmetrically on either side of the magnet, at equal distances from its centre, in the east–west direction. This is the case already plotted in Fig. 10.7-2.
  4. If the south pole of the magnet faces the geographic north, the neutral points are on either side of the magnet at equal distances from its centre, in the north–south directions, as plotted in Fig. 10.7-3.

Diagram

Fig. 10.8-1 — Neutral Point Between Two Magnets With Like Poles Facing Two bar magnets drawn horizontally in one straight line with a gap between them. The left magnet has S at its left end and N at its right end; the right magnet has N at its left end and S at its right end, so that two north poles face each other across the gap. Draw a short arrow in the gap pointing rightwards, starting from the left magnet’s N pole and labelled ‘field of the left magnet’; draw a second short arrow in the gap pointing leftwards, starting from the right magnet’s N pole and labelled ‘field of the right magnet’. Mark a cross at the point in the gap where the two arrows meet and label it ‘neutral point’.

Diagram

Fig. 10.8-2 — Neutral Point Above A Vertical Magnet A bar magnet drawn standing upright on a table with N at its top end and S at its bottom end. A vertical dashed line drawn upwards from the N pole. On this line, well above the magnet, mark a cross labelled ‘neutral point’. Draw a short arrow at the cross pointing vertically upwards labelled ‘field of the magnet’, and a second short arrow at the same point pointing vertically downwards labelled ‘vertical component of the earth’s field’, the two arrows drawn equal in length.

In every one of these cases the test is the same. Look for the place where the two fields present are equal in size and exactly opposed in direction, and that is where the compass needle will lose its bearings.

Where The Neutral Point Lies Between Two Magnets

1. What is given, and what is asked — two identical bar magnets are laid on a table in one straight line, a short distance apart, with their north poles facing each other. We must find where the neutral point lies between them.

  1. The reasoning used — this is case 1. A neutral point needs two fields equal in magnitude and opposite in direction. In the gap, the field of the left magnet points to the right, away from its north pole, and the field of the right magnet points to the left, away from its north pole. They are already opposite in direction everywhere in the gap, so all that remains is to find where they are equal in size.

  2. The working — the field of a magnet decreases as the distance from it increases. Moving from the left magnet towards the right one, the field of the left magnet falls and the field of the right magnet rises. Since the two magnets are identical, the two fields are equal at the point that is the same distance from each — the mid-point of the gap.

  3. The answer — the neutral point is at the middle of the gap between the two magnets. A compass needle placed there would rest in any direction. As a check, note that if one magnet were the stronger of the two, the point of balance would shift towards the weaker magnet, which is where the stronger magnet’s field has fallen enough to match it.

A bar magnet is placed on a table along the magnetic meridian, and a compass needle is moved slowly eastwards from the centre of the magnet along a straight line. Describe how the behaviour of the needle changes along the way, state what you would observe at one particular point, and name that point. Then state which pole of the magnet must be facing the geographic north for this to happen.

10.9 Summary

  1. Lodestone is a naturally occurring ore of iron oxide, \(\\mathrm{Fe\_3O\_4}\), which attracts small pieces of iron and sets itself along a definite direction when suspended freely. Pieces of lodestone are called natural magnets.

  2. Natural magnets are of odd shapes and are not magnetically strong enough for use, so artificial magnets are made from iron and steel in convenient shapes — the bar magnet, the horse shoe magnet, the magnetic needle and the magnetic compass.

  3. A magnet suspended by a silk thread so that it is free to turn in a horizontal plane always comes to rest along the geographic north–south direction. The end that turns towards the geographic north is the north pole of the magnet, and the other end is its south pole.

  4. Two like poles repel each other, while two unlike poles attract each other.

  5. A magnetic material, such as soft iron or steel, is one that a magnet can attract and that can itself be magnetised.

  6. The temporary magnetism acquired by a magnetic material when it is kept near, or in contact with, a magnet is called induced magnetism. The process by which it acquires these properties is called magnetic induction.

  7. A magnetic pole induces an opposite polarity on the near end of an iron bar and a similar polarity on its farther end.

  8. Induction precedes attraction. A piece of iron first becomes a magnet by induction, its near end acquiring the opposite polarity, and only then is it attracted, because unlike poles attract.

  9. Magnetism acquired by induction is purely temporary. It lasts only as long as the magnet causing the induction remains in the neighbourhood, which is why a chain of iron nails hanging from a magnet collapses the moment the magnet is taken away.

  10. The space around a magnet in which the needle of a compass rests in a direction other than the geographic north–south direction is called the magnetic field of the magnet. Its effect decreases as the distance from the magnet increases.

  11. Magnetic field is a vector quantity. Its magnitude at a point is measured by the force experienced by a magnetic pole of unit strength placed there, and its direction is the direction in which the north pole of a compass needle rests when placed at that point.

  12. Iron filings sprinkled on a plate over a magnet and gently tapped arrange themselves along curved lines, because each filing is magnetised by induction and then experiences a force. These curved lines are the magnetic field lines.

  13. A magnetic field line is a continuous curve in a magnetic field such that the tangent at any point of the curve gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point. An arrow is marked on it from the south pole of the compass needle towards its north pole.

  14. The magnetic field lines have the following properties.

  • They are closed and continuous curves.
  • Outside the magnet they are directed from the north pole towards the south pole, and inside it from the south pole to the north pole.
  • The tangent at any point on a field line gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point.
  • They never intersect one another, since the field cannot have two directions at one point.
  • They are crowded near the poles where the field is strong, and far apart near the middle of the magnet and far from it where the field is weak.
  • Parallel and equidistant field lines represent a uniform magnetic field, and the earth’s magnetic field in a limited space is uniform.
  • They behave like stretched elastic rubber strings.
  1. The existence of the earth’s magnetic field is inferred from four facts.
  • A freely suspended magnetic needle always rests in the geographic north–south direction.
  • An iron rod buried inside the earth along the north–south direction becomes a weak magnet.
  • Neutral points are obtained on plotting the field lines of a magnet, where the net magnetic field is zero.
  • A magnetic needle rests making different angles with the horizontal when suspended at different places on the earth.
  1. The two places where a magnetic needle free to turn in a vertical plane becomes vertical are called the magnetic poles of the earth. The line joining the places where such a needle becomes horizontal is called the magnetic equator.

  2. The earth behaves as if a huge bar magnet were placed at its centre, with its magnetic south pole in the geographic north and its magnetic north pole in the geographic south. The magnetic axis makes an angle of \(17^\\circ\) with the axis of rotation, and the positions of the magnetic poles change gradually over long periods of time.

  3. The magnetic field lines of the earth are normal to the earth’s surface near the magnetic poles and parallel to the earth’s surface near the magnetic equator. In a limited space they are parallel and equidistant, and they are always directed from the geographic south to the geographic north.

  4. The uniform field lines of the earth are plotted with a small compass needle on paper held by brass pins, marking successive pairs of dots in front of the ends of the needle and joining them. The lines obtained are straight, parallel, equidistant and non-intersecting.

  5. The magnetic field around a bar magnet or a horse shoe magnet is non-uniform. Its field lines are not equispaced and parallel but curved, either converging or diverging; closely spaced lines mean a strong field and widely spaced lines a weak field.

  6. To plot the field of a bar magnet, the magnet is laid along the magnetic meridian, either with its north pole pointing north or with its south pole pointing north. The pattern obtained is always due to the combined effect of the magnet’s field and the earth’s field.

  7. Near the magnet the plotted lines are curved, because the magnet’s field is the stronger there. At distant points they become nearly parallel straight lines running from south to north, because the earth’s field is the stronger there.

  8. Neutral points are the points at which two magnetic fields are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction. The net magnetic field at a neutral point is zero, and a compass needle placed there rests in any direction.

  9. The earth’s magnetic field has a horizontal component directed from the geographic south to the geographic north, and a vertical component directed vertically downwards in the northern hemisphere.

  10. The positions of the neutral points depend on how the magnet is placed.

  • For two magnets in one line with their like poles facing each other, the neutral point lies between the two magnets.
  • For a magnet standing vertical with its north pole up, the neutral point lies on the vertical line away from its north pole.
  • If the north pole of the magnet faces the geographic north, the neutral points lie on either side of it at equal distances from its centre, in the east–west direction.
  • If the south pole of the magnet faces the geographic north, the neutral points lie on either side of it at equal distances from its centre, in the north–south direction.

Flowchart

FC 10.2 — Why A Magnet Attracts An Unmagnetised Piece Of Iron Magnet brought near the iron → near end of the iron acquires the opposite polarity by magnetic induction → the near end and the facing pole of the magnet are now unlike poles → unlike poles attract → the iron is drawn towards the magnet → magnet taken away → the induced magnetism is lost and the attraction ceases

10.10 Key Terms

  1. Artificial magnet — a magnet manufactured from iron or steel in a convenient shape and size, made because natural magnets are irregular and too weak for use.

  2. Bar magnet — an artificial magnet in the form of a straight rectangular bar, with a north pole at one end and a south pole at the other.

  3. Horse shoe magnet — an artificial magnet bent into a U shape so that its two poles face the same way, close to each other.

  4. Induced magnetism — the temporary magnetism acquired by a magnetic material when it is kept near, or in contact with, a magnet.

  5. Lodestone — a naturally occurring ore of iron oxide, \(\\mathrm{Fe\_3O\_4}\), which attracts small pieces of iron and sets itself along a definite direction when freely suspended.

  6. Magnetic axis of the earth — the line joining the two magnetic poles of the earth, which makes an angle of \(17^\\circ\) with the earth’s axis of rotation.

  7. Magnetic compass — a magnetic needle pivoted inside a small box over a marked dial, used to find direction.

  8. Magnetic equator — the line joining the places on the earth’s surface where a magnetic needle free to turn in a vertical plane rests horizontal.

  9. Magnetic field — the space around a magnet in which a compass needle rests in a direction other than the geographic north–south direction; a vector quantity, measured in tesla (T).

  10. Magnetic field line — a continuous curve in a magnetic field such that the tangent at any point of the curve gives the direction of the magnetic field at that point.

  11. Magnetic induction — the process by which a piece of magnetic material acquires magnetic properties temporarily in the presence of another magnet near it.

  12. Magnetic material — a material such as soft iron or steel which a magnet can attract and which can itself be magnetised.

  13. Magnetic meridian — the direction in which a freely suspended magnet comes to rest, that is, the geographic north–south direction.

  14. Magnetic needle — a slender magnet balanced on a sharp pivot so that it is free to swing in a horizontal plane.

  15. Magnetic poles of the earth — the two places on the earth’s surface where a magnetic needle free to turn in a vertical plane rests vertical.

  16. Natural magnet — a piece of lodestone found in the earth, magnetic as it is dug out, without being manufactured.

  17. Neutral point — a point at which two magnetic fields are equal in magnitude but opposite in direction, so that the net magnetic field there is zero.

  18. North pole of a magnet — the end of a freely suspended magnet that turns towards the geographic north.

  19. South pole of a magnet — the end of a freely suspended magnet that turns towards the geographic south.

  20. Uniform magnetic field — a field having the same magnitude and the same direction at every point in the region, represented by parallel and equidistant field lines.

10.11 Points To Ponder

  1. Iron filings tapped on a plate settle into a pattern, and we say the pattern reveals the field lines. But the filings are objects and the lines are drawings. In what sense, then, does a magnetic field exist at a point where nothing at all has been placed?

  2. A soft iron bar loses its induced magnetism the instant the magnet is taken away, while a steel bar magnet keeps its magnetism for years with nothing near it. What might be different inside the two materials to account for such different behaviour?

  3. The magnetic poles of the earth are known to shift gradually over long periods. If the earth’s magnetic poles were one day to exchange places, what would change for a ship’s compass, for a plotted field diagram, and for a migrating bird — and what would not change at all?

  4. At a neutral point the resultant magnetic field is zero, so a compass needle placed there is left undisturbed. Would a small iron nail placed at that same point also stay where it is put? Think carefully about the fact that a nail has length, and that the field a short distance away is not zero.

  5. The north pole of a compass needle is attracted towards the geographic north, which means the earth has a magnetic south pole up there. Was the naming of the poles a mistake, or does it make sense once you know how the names were chosen? What would have to be renamed if the convention were reversed today?

  6. Field lines are said to behave like stretched elastic rubber strings, and this picture explains neatly why unlike poles are drawn together and like poles pushed apart. Where else does the picture serve you well, and is there anything about a magnetic field that a rubber string could never capture?

10.12 Objective Questions

  1. A magnetic pole induces on the near end of an iron bar a polarity which is: (1 mark)
    1. similar to its own
    2. opposite to its own
    3. always north
    4. always south
  2. Inside a magnet, the magnetic field lines are directed: (1 mark)
    1. from the north pole to the south pole
    2. from the south pole to the north pole
    3. from both poles towards the middle
    4. nowhere, since no lines exist inside a magnet
  3. Magnetic field lines which are parallel and equidistant represent: (1 mark)
    1. a uniform magnetic field
    2. a converging magnetic field
    3. a diverging magnetic field
    4. a region of zero magnetic field
  4. The magnetic axis of the earth makes with its axis of rotation an angle of about: (1 mark)
    1. \(0^\\circ\)
    2. \(17^\\circ\)
    3. \(45^\\circ\)
    4. \(90^\\circ\)
  5. A bar magnet is placed along the magnetic meridian with its south pole pointing towards the geographic north. Its neutral points lie: (1 mark)
    1. in the east and west directions
    2. in the north and south directions
    3. at the two poles of the magnet
    4. nowhere, since none are formed
  6. A magnetic needle free to turn in a vertical plane rests parallel to the earth’s surface at the: (1 mark)
    1. magnetic poles
    2. magnetic equator
    3. geographic poles
    4. neutral points
  7. Which of the following is a magnetic material? (1 mark)
    1. copper
    2. brass
    3. soft iron
    4. aluminium
  8. While plotting magnetic field lines, the sheet of paper is fixed with brass pins because brass: (1 mark)
    1. is a good conductor of heat
    2. is not a magnetic material
    3. is lighter than iron
    4. does not rust

For each of the following, choose the correct option from the codes given below. (1 mark each) a. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A b. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A c. A is false but R is true d. A is true but R is false

  1. Assertion (A): A compass needle placed at a neutral point rests in any direction. Reason (R): The resultant magnetic field at a neutral point is zero.

  2. Assertion (A): Iron filings sprinkled over a plate covering a bar magnet arrange themselves along curved lines when the plate is tapped. Reason (R): Each filing becomes a magnet by induction and then experiences a force due to the magnet.

  3. Assertion (A): The magnetism induced in a soft iron bar by a nearby magnet is permanent. Reason (R): Induced magnetism lasts only so long as the magnet causing the induction stays in the vicinity.

  4. Match each item in Column A with the correct item in Column B. (5 marks)

Column A Column B
a. Lodestone i. Its net magnetic field is zero
b. Magnetic equator ii. A naturally occurring ore of iron oxide
c. Neutral point iii. Parallel and equidistant field lines
d. Uniform field iv. The direction in which a freely suspended magnet rests
e. Magnetic meridian v. The needle of a dip circle rests horizontal here
  1. Complete the following sentences. (4 marks)

    1. Outside a magnet, magnetic field lines are directed from the ………. pole towards the ………. pole.
    2. The magnetism acquired by a magnetic material kept near a magnet is called ………. magnetism.
    3. The magnetic field lines of the earth are ………. to the earth’s surface near the magnetic poles.
    4. The horizontal component of the earth’s magnetic field is directed from the geographic ………. to the geographic ……….
  2. State whether each statement is true or false. (3 marks)

    1. Two magnetic field lines may cross each other where the field is very strong.
    2. Magnetic field lines are crowded near the poles of a magnet.
    3. The magnetic poles of the earth stay at fixed positions for all time.
  3. Name the following. (3 marks)

    1. The ore whose pieces were the first known magnets.
    2. The points near a bar magnet at which a compass needle rests in any direction.
    3. The shape of magnet whose two poles lie close together and face the same way.
  4. Give one word or phrase for each of the following. (2 marks)

    1. The process by which a piece of soft iron acquires magnetic properties temporarily in the presence of a magnet.
    2. A field having the same magnitude and direction at every point of a region.
  5. State the SI unit of magnetic field. (1 mark)

  6. Pick the odd one out and give a reason for your choice: bar magnet, horse shoe magnet, lodestone, magnetic needle. (1 mark)

10.13 Check Your Concepts

  1. Define induced magnetism. (2 marks)

  2. State the law of magnetic poles. (2 marks)

  3. What is a lodestone? State the two properties by which it was recognised. (2 marks)

  4. Why are artificial magnets preferred to natural magnets? Give two reasons. (2 marks)

  5. Give a reason for the following: a compass needle placed at a neutral point does not settle in any particular direction. (2 marks)

  6. Differentiate between induced magnetism and permanent magnetism, stating the basis of difference. (3 marks)

  7. State any three properties of magnetic field lines. (3 marks)

  8. Why does the spacing between magnetic field lines change from place to place around a bar magnet? What does close spacing indicate? (3 marks)

  9. Explain the statement ‘induction precedes attraction’ with reference to a piece of soft iron brought near one pole of a magnet. (3 marks)

  10. Two magnetic field lines can never intersect each other. Give the reason, and state what would follow if they did. (3 marks)

  11. State any four evidences for the existence of the earth’s magnetic field. (4 marks)

  12. Several soft iron nails hang one below the other in a chain from one pole of a bar magnet. Explain how the chain forms, why it stops growing at a certain length, and what happens when the magnet is withdrawn. (4 marks)

  13. What is meant by a neutral point? State the positions of the neutral points when a bar magnet is placed in the magnetic meridian with (i) its north pole pointing towards the geographic north, and (ii) its south pole pointing towards the geographic north. (4 marks)

  14. Describe how the uniform magnetic field lines of the earth are plotted in a limited space using a small compass needle. State two features of the pattern obtained, and explain why brass pins are used to fix the paper. (5 marks)

  15. What would happen if the earth suddenly lost its magnetic field? Discuss the effect on a freely suspended magnet, on a plotted field pattern of a bar magnet, and on the neutral points near that magnet. (5 marks)

10.14 Diagrams, Graphs & Constructions

  1. Draw a neat labelled diagram of a bar magnet suspended freely by a silk thread from a rigid support. Mark the polarity of its two ends and indicate the geographic north–south direction. (3 marks)

  2. A soft iron bar \(PQ\) is placed in line with a bar magnet, with the north pole of the magnet facing end \(P\). Draw the arrangement, mark the polarity induced at \(P\) and at \(Q\), and state which of the two ends will attract the magnet. (3 marks)

  3. Fig. 10.7-2 shows the field lines of a bar magnet placed along the magnetic meridian with its north pole facing the geographic north. Redraw the pattern, mark the two neutral points with crosses, and state the direction in which they lie from the centre of the magnet. (4 marks)

  4. Sketch four magnetic field lines as obtained on a horizontal plane in a limited space in the earth’s magnetic field alone. Put an arrowhead on each line, and state what the spacing of your lines tells you about the field. (3 marks)

  5. Two bar magnets are placed on a table in one straight line with a gap between them, their north poles facing each other. Draw the arrangement, mark the likely position of the neutral point with a cross, and give a reason for the position you have chosen. (4 marks)

  6. Fig. 10.4-2 shows two field lines drawn crossing each other at a point \(P\). Copy the figure, mark the point \(P\), and state with a reason why no field diagram may ever be drawn in this way. (3 marks)

  7. Draw a labelled diagram of the earth showing it as a huge bar magnet placed at its centre. Mark the geographic poles, the magnetic poles, the magnetic axis and the axis of rotation, and show the angle between the two axes. (5 marks)